Monday, November 04, 2019

what can be accomplished in a week

This idea is relevant to aseres ymei teshuvah, but what can I do -- the idea only came up here in parshas Noach.
     
Subtract Rosh haShana and Yom Kippur and aseres ymei teshuvah amounts to one week.  One week to correct a year, a lifetime's work of mistakes!  How is that possible?
     
Rashi observes that at the beginning of the parsha Noach is called a "tzadik tamim," yet when Hashem appears to Noach to tell him to enter the ark he tells him that "oscha ra'isi tzadik lifanei," he is a tzadik -- Hashem leaves out the word "tamim."
     
Ksav Sofer offers an original explanation (see Rashi for a different explanation) for the discrepancy: Rashi writes that Hashem delayed the command to enter the ark until the after the seven days of mourning for Mesushelach were completed.  Mesushelach was a tzadik, so long as he was alive, the flood was held off.  Ksav Sofer adds that so long as Mesushelach was alive, Noach was also not held accountable for failing to rebuke the people or for failing to daven on their behalf.  Why should he have that responsibility when there was a tzadik like Mesushelach around?  However, once Mesushelach died, the world rested on Noach's shoulders.  Since Noach at that point still remained passive and did nothing, some of the shine of his tzidkus was lost.  He was no longer a "tzadik tamim," but merely a "tzadik."
     
Mesushelach lived 969 years -- he literally had hundreds of years to try to make an impression on the people around him, to arouse them to teshuvah.  When he died, Noach had one week to step in and fill his shoes before the flood hit.  Imagine a shul where the Rabbi has held the pulpit for decades and has not made a dent in raising the religious observance of the community, not for lack of effort, but for lack of a receptive audience.  The Rabbi passes away, and the assistant Rabbi must now step in.  Are you going to hold the assistant accountable for failing to reach the community mamesh during the week of shiva of his predecessor when his predecessor couldn't reach them in the decades he served?!  Here too, what kind of knock it is on Noach's tzidkus when he couldn't do anything in only a week when Mesushelach was no more successful in centuries?!
     
Yet the Torah doesn't see things that way.  Who knows what you can accomplish is a week of dedicated effort?  Remember, Hashem would have saved Sdom had there only been a minyan of tzadikim there.  Noach didn't have to reach the entire world -- he could have focused on one, on a handful, of people and that might have tilted the balance to prevent the flood. 

4 comments:

  1. "Noach at that point"

    at the very beginning of the seven days?! how could he be judged in advance for the week to come? by chazakah? (it cannot be that he had only seven seconds to prove himself; John McClane yes, but Noach, no)

    Mesushelach lost his son Lemech five years earlier: had the father sinned one time in his long past, a single sin punishable by kares? Noach had done no such thing, so he was "tamim" by compare. as of >day one< of Mesushelach's death, Noach was not quite perfect anymore, for lack of favorable comparison.

    still, a week is a week and the King was in the field. Noach "could have focused...on a handful...of people", namely the surviving sons and daughters of Mesushelach (5:26) who, mourning their father despite themselves and losing for cover his living merit, were maybe more persuadable than ever...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great heara, that the taina was not that he didn't change the whole world. The tainah is that he should have at least changed two or three people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Mesushelach was a tzadik"

    and his son, "assistant Rabbi" Lemech, a demi-tzadik [a benoni?]. when he named his son at 5:29, Lemech foresaw >twowork<. as ish ha'adamah, the grandson/son introduced free wine-tasting and fig-nibbling* to attract the errant masses to M & L mussar talks. no longer would the two rabbis need to chase all over the map and back catching at ignorant ears.

    the problem: once Noach received word to enter the ark at 7:1, on that very day he closed up shop. no more wine, no more fig rolls, during the last seven days before the flood. as he packed the kiruv apparatus away the better to pack the teivah for her voyage, delicate "tamim" flew out the window...


    *see Rashi, vine and fig shoots, 9:20c

    ReplyDelete
  4. to combine & conclude:

    with the death of Mesushelach [following the death of Lemech five years prior], Noach would need to step in and give his first mussar shmuess ever, during the shiva week, to the permanently distracted profane ears of wine-sippers and fig-nibblers. not only did he leave that task undone [but instead closed shop], he didn't try to intensify the desultory weeping of Mesushelach's surviving children through eulogy, nor provide them a seudat havra'ah of his finest wine, his fattest fig [though by the two together he might have prevailed on just these individuals at last]. {darkened speculation has it that Noach's first words* were to the incoming animals, long before Dr. Dolittle perfected that skill. not quite the "ruach m'malela" that Hashem had in mind...}

    *prior to 'arur' at 9:25. of course his good deeds spoke much sooner (and louder, perhaps, than words)

    ReplyDelete