One of my daughters mentioned on Shabbos that she learned in school that if one does melacha on Shabbos one cannot have benefit from that work, e.g. (her example) if you turn on a light, you would not be allowed to sit and read by that light. But is this correct? (I admit: I am naturally suspicious of anything my kids learn in school : ) The gemara's discussion of this halacha uses the example of violating the issur of bishul. The Chayei Adam has a safeik whether the rule would be the same for a melacha where the object has not changed - e.g. if one violated the melacha of carrying in a reshus harabim, would one be prohibited from having benefit from the object? When one turns on a light, the wiring of one's home has not changed - it has simply started carrying a current. On the other hand, the bulb that was dark has now become illuminated. Is this comparable to ma'avir or bishul??
Another interesting safeik is whether this halacha applies to issurei derabbanan as well as issurei d'oraysa. One could debate whether tuning on a light in indeed an issur d'oraysa (too lengthy a discussion for now).
I don't know how much of these details my daughter absorbed in our few minute discussion, but then again, I wonder if her teacher thought through them when presenting the case (yes, I should give her the benefit of the doubt).
Sunday, February 26, 2006
Deriving benefit from melacha done on Shabbos
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you! latino women brown hair blue eyesReplyDelete
Wonderful and informative web site. I used information from that site its great. latin leo Teenage girls in peeing pics pamela anderson nude personals trannys fat hairy lesbians Gagged babes fucked Big massive cock Small girls with small tits and nice ass Bilder paris hilton Amber s fat ass Homemade bikini Sex disene toons myspace fort walton foot fetish Xxx porn blonde pussy anal penetration porn star biographies paris hilton caps Rate asians nudesReplyDelete
[color=red]The Most Affordable XRUMER/BACKLINK SERVICE Online!ReplyDelete
The EFFORTLESS and POWERFUL WAY TO BUILD MASSIVE # OF BACKLINKS
200,000 BLASTS of your URLs+ Anchor Tex, message, pictures (can be spinned) etc
$10 USD (shared with other clients like a carpool), or
$25/200k for exclusive!(you control EVERYTHING)
$50 Exclusive @ 500,000 blasts.
(Complete reports will be given to clients)
For orders, questions or concerns? Email: [u]formless.void47 at gmail.com [/u]
1. For STRICT Whitehat sites, it is advised to create buffers to pass on linkjuice. i.e. social bookmarks, cloaked pages etc.
You can blast the site directly, but it entails risk.
Using buffers are 100% safe, speaking from experience.
2. Xrumer is a very technical tool. Just describe to me what sorts of effects you want and well make it happen!
If you want to buy Xrumer?
>>>>> http://cloakedlink.com/chzgykebsd <<<<<<
CLIENT 2 SAMPLE SPACE FILLED WITH URLs,Pics and Keywords
seo ip seo howto search engine optimization seo monitoring tool Buy Link Post seo audit seo israel charlotte seo buy fedex seo tips uk seo company florida seo sem seo norwich ethical seo company aaron wall seo seo review search engine strategies seo fathom seo seo nottingham good seo seo gold seo company mumbai black hat seo techniques seo help seo services mumbai seo doncaster seo browser seo meta tags seo article writing seo magazine link buying seo link tool seo secrets beanstalk seo seo optimising seo consultant ahmedabad buy d link rangebooster xrumer free search engine promotion seo software uk seo marketing company Link Where To Buy white seo Xrumer 29 cheapest seo guy seo services pricing seo evaluation seo elite tutorial seo information
CLIENT 3 SAMPLE SPACE
[url=http://provenheightincrease.co.cc/ebook/casual-shoe-to-gain-height]casual shoe to gain height[/url] http://provenheightincrease.co.cc/ebook/casual-shoe-to-gain-height
[url=http://herpeset.co.cc/cheap/Herpes-Love-Herpes-Help-Herpes-On-Stomach.html]herpes love herpes help herpes on stomach[/url]
CLIENT 4 SAMPLE SPACE
[url=http://provenheightincrease.co.cc/ebook/increase-kids-height]increase kids height[/url] http://provenheightincrease.co.cc/ebook/increase-kids-height
[url=http://growyourdick.co.cc/penile/penis-lengthening-surgery]penis lengthening surgery[/url] http://growyourdick.co.cc/penile/penis-lengthening-surgery
http://buycheapplasmatv.info/cgi-bin/index.pl?=best-price-plasma-tv [url=http://buycheapplasmatv.info/cgi-bin/index.pl?=best-price-plasma-tv]best price plasma tv[/url]
[url=http://teethwhiteningstripsreviews.info/xr/new-york-teeth-whitening]plasma light tooth whitening tooth whitening cost lancaster ohio teeth whitening natural teeth whitening remedies East Hampshire opulence teeth whitening lincoln nebraska teeth whitening St. Paul disadvantages of tooth whitening Sikkim[/url]
CLIENT 5 SAMPLE SPACE
[url=http://cheapxrumerservice.co.cc]Cheap Xrumer Service[/url]
[url=http://cheapxrumerservice.co.cc]Cheapest Xrumer Service[/url]
[url=http://cheapxrumerservice.co.cc]Best Xrumer Service[/url]
http://cheappleodinosaurprices2.wetpaint.com/##Pleo A Ugobe Life Form Pleo Auction Pleo Best Pleo Dinosaur A Ugobe Life Form Pleo Dinosaur Price
http://cheaphdtvplasma.co.cc/television/plasma-video-wall [url=http://cheaphdtvplasma.co.cc/television/plasma-video-wall]plasma video wall[/url]
[url=http://stopacaiberryscams.info/cgi-bin/index.pl/acai-pill-on]acai pill on[/url]
I truly appreciate this publish. I¡¦vet been looking all over for this! Thank advantages I discovered it on Google. You have designed my day! Thanks againReplyDelete
best seo services in bangalore | best seo services bangalore