Ramban answers that a korban chatas is required because the nazir’s
return to everyday life is a step down from the spiritual heights he reached
during his nezirus. A return to the
everyday world is a surrender to the drives and desires that the nazir avoided
while in his higher spiritual state of nezirus.
Rabeinu Bachyei disagrees.
We never find, he writes, a korban chatas offered for future sins that
have not yet been committed; a chatas is only brought after one has already
sinned. When the nazir steps back into the
mundane everyday routine that may include drinking wine, taking a haircut,
etc., he has not yet done anything wrong.
The korbanos of the nazir, explains R’ Bachyei, are not
brought because of any sin (he does not say it explicitly, but it seems that
this chatas is an exception to the norm because it is brought together with the
olah and shelamim). The root of the word
korban is k-r-v, to draw closer; the
purpose of the nazir’s korbanos is to draw him closer to the source of his spiritual
energy, to give him a final boost that he can carry into his regular day to day. “V’achar yishteh ha’nazir ya’yin” – the Torah
ends the parsha by telling us that the nazir should return to his everyday life
of the past. The purpose of nezirus is
not to escape from the mundane world, but to learn how to live in it properly.
Hopefully your Shavuos was celebrated with intense immersion
in talmud torah and kabbalas haTorah, and so it’s only natural to feel a bit
letdown on isru chag. Rabeinu Bachyei’s
perspective reminds us that islands of spirituality are not meant as an oasis
of temporary escape from the day to day, a momentary high from which we must fall, but are meant to
give us the spiritual vitamins we need so our day to day becomes infused with that spiritual intensity and energy as well.
If I understand your comments in the parentheses - you mean that this is not a "real" Karban Chatas since he did not commit any sin...?
ReplyDelete(It's just a technical reason why he brings a KCh.?)
Its own true. We are not interested unless it involves girl gaga. Which by the way is gematria amaleik.
ReplyDeleteI don't think they know what amalek is. And welcome back!
ReplyDeleteRe: the korban chatas, I'm struggling to make sense of how acc. to R' Bachyei it can be called a korban chatas when it doesn't really have anything to do with sin. What I wrote prob isn't clear because I don't have a clear idea.