The Ben Ish Chai in his Shut Rav Paalim III:32, left side of the page here brings proof from sefiras ha'omer that just like there is an issur of chatzi shiur, there is a kiyum mitzvah even if one fulfills only part of a required shiur.
According to BH"G, sefiras ha'omer is one mitzvah that requires completing a count of 49 days. How can a person recite a bracha on counting when there is always the possibility of missing a night and failing to complete the mitzvah? QED, says the Ben Ish Chai, that there is a kiyum even in doing part of the mitzvah, and that kiyum is sufficient to recite a bracha on.
Halacha l'maaseh this issue comes up in cases where a person knows they will inevitably miss counting a day of sefirah for some reason. Should they still count up until that point with a bracha, or should they skip making a bracha from the get-go knowing that they will be unable to complete the cycle?
(An additional factor to throw into the mix in such a case is whether, if a person misses a day, we in fact view the brachos made on the previous days as brachos l'vatala or not?)
There are four separate chiddushim here in this Ben Ish Chai:
1) the assertion that chatzi shiur counts as a kiyum mitzvah, which we discussed here
2) the assertion that one can say a bracha on chatzi shiur (AH"S, among others, disagrees. He writes 477:3 that there is a kiyum mitzvah in eating a chatzi shiur of matzah, but no bracha should be recited.)
3) the assertion that there should be a concern that one may not complete the 49 day count.
4) lastly, something bothers me about treating part of sefirah, or part of any unit of time, as a chatzi shiur, but unfortunately I can't seem to put my thumb on formulating what exactly it is that bothers me. Maybe someone can do a better job at it. If a person fasts half a day, for example, would you call that a chatzi shiur of a taanis? (Maybe that's the machlokes Mechaber/Rama whether one should say aneinu at every tefilah or not, lest one fail to complete the fast?)
על ח"ש אינו מברך על אכילת מצה, שאין אכילה פחותה מכזית
ReplyDeletegood point
Delete