Wednesday, July 17, 2013

temunas Hashem yabit

The local Young Israels joined forces yesterday to present a 9 Av afternoon program in which the Rabbis each took a turn to speak.  One thought from R’ Heshy Blumstein, Rabbi of the YI of Hewlett, still stands out in my mind:

Moshe Rabeinu is told in response to the nechashim ha’serafim, the plague of snakes that attacked Bnei Yisrael as a punishment for their complaints, to make a snake and place it on a staff and anyone who is bitten, “v’hibit el nechash hanechoshes v’chai,” should look at that snake and live (Bamidbar 21:9). 

The Torah has warning after warning about idolatry; we are prohibited from making graven images.  How can the Torah here command Moshe to make an image of a snake and davka have people look at that image to be healed?

R’ Blumstein quoted his rebbe, R’ Zweig from Miami, as suggesting an answer based on Rashi back in Parshas Lech Lecha (Braishis 15:5).  Avraham is lifted above the Heavens and is told to look down at the stars, “habet na ha’shamayma,” as his children will be as multitudinous as those innumerable constellations.  Rashi comments from the Midrash that Avraham was raised above the starts to show that Jewish destiny transcends mazal, it is above what astrology and natural forces dictate, and this is why the Torah there uses the term “habet,” as “lashon habara m’m’ma’alah l’matah,” Rashi explains that “habet” always means looking down from a higher perspective.

Returning to the parsha of the snakes, Moshe indeed made an image of a snake, but the whole point was to engender that response of “v’hibit el nechash ha’nechoshes,” the key word being "hibit," looking down at that snake, i.e. realizing that Klal Yisrael stood on a higher plane.  The whole point was that snakes, images, and other forces have no power.

So far so good, but here’s the part that R’ Blumstein said that if you only came to hear this, it was worth it, and I agree:

There is another place in the Torah where the same root as “hibit” is used and there this pshat doesn’t seem to fit at all.  When Miriam speaks against Moshe, Hashem comes and tells her and Aharon that Moshe is not like any other prophet.  “Peh el peh adaber bo, b’mareh v’lo b’chidos, u’temunas Hashem yabit…”  (Bamidbar 12:8) If “yabit” means to look down on something else, like "hibit," then how does this pasuk make any sense?  How could Hashem defend Moshe by telling Aharon and Miriam that he chas v’shalom looks down on high on the “temunas Hashem?” 

The Lubavitcher Rebbe explained that this pasuk is referring to a situation where Bnei Yisrael sin and fall to the lowest depths.  When a prophet then comes and stands over them, looking down at their errant behavior, what does that prophet see?  Undoubtedly, that prophet sees the worst in people and will come to give tochacha.  Not so Moshe Rabeinu, says Hashem.  Even though Moshe stood above the people, on a much higher spiritual plane, when he looked down on them, even when he saw all their foibles and misguided ways, for him it was still “temunas Hashem yabit,” he still saw the image of G-d in Klal Yisrael.  That’s what a true leader is.  That’s the perspective to take away from Tisha b’Av.

Monday, July 15, 2013

9 Av -- commemoration of the churban or of all tragedies?

I noticed that with respect to describing the fall of Betar, which took place on 9 Av, the Rambam (Ta'anis 5:3) writes:
ונלכדה עיר גדולה ובית תור היה שמה והיו בה אלפים ורבבות מישראל, והיה להם מלך גדול ודימו כל ישראל וגדולי החכמים שהוא המלך המשיח, ונפל ביד גויים ונהרגו כולם, והייתה צרה גדולה כמו חורבן המקדש
Why does the Rambam needs to add that the calamity was so great that it was like the churban?  Isn't that derash, not halacha?
I haven't looked around to check if anyone says this, but it sounds like the Rambam holds that the mourning of 9 Av was instituted specifically for churban-related events. The fall fall of Betar, as great a calamity as it was, is thrown into the mix only because it was an event that in the eyes of Chazal could be equated with the churban itself. Would the Rambam agree with Rashi (Divrei haYamim II 35:25) that ALL tragic events should be commemorated in the kinos of 9 Av?

learning on 9 Av

My son asked me about learning a certain sefer on 9 Av on hil aveilus given that this sefer might count as more of iyun.  I pointed him to the GR”A in siman 554 who is medayek that the shulchan aruch says that it is permissible “lilmod,” to learn -– not just to read -- things like eilu megalchim (hil aveilus) and midrash Eicha (see the Beis Yosef as well).  The proof comes from a Yerushalmi in Shabbos (kol kisvei) that tells us of two of the Amoraim who were learning midrash Eicha on erev 9 Av which fell on Shabbos.  They couldn’t finish that day so they said to each other, “Let’s pick up tomorrow.”  The implication is that the limud of Tisha b’Av in midrash Eicha would be the same as that of Shabbos erev 9 Av – no difference in depth or analysis. 

Of course, it goes without saying that the rest of the year we should be doing “limud” – not just reading and turning the pages – when we are engaged in talmud Torah (and I probably need to take this to heart more than anyone else reading this.)

R' Soloveitchik on tefillin of Tisha b'Av

Even though on Tisha b'Av we practice nihugei aveilus, e.g. sitting on the floor, and even nihugei aninus, like not learning Torah, one exception to the rule that stands out is the fact that we wear tefillin even though an aveil on yom rishon does not.  Why is this particular din the exception?

R’ Soloveitchik explained that there are 2 dinim in aveilus: there are nihugei aveilus, the do’s and don’ts, and there is the shem aveil on the gavra. 

Even though according to the Rambam m’doraysa there is only one day of aveilus, the Rambam brings l’halacha the din (M.K. 15) that an aveil may not send korbanos to the mikdash for all 7 days.  Even though m’doraysa the nihugei aveilus apply only on one day, the shem aveil is there for all seven.  (Rav Wahrman in his She’eris Yosef vol 2 gives a different teirutz: even if aveilus is derabbanan, the person is not thinking straight so there is a chisaron in da’as ba’alim of the korban.  However, see the Ritv”a who holds the whole din applies only to shelamim but not chatas – tzarich biur.)

When there are no kerovim the halacha is that you still have 10 people practice nihugei aveilus for the meis – there is obviously no shem aveil on the gavra, as the meis is not related to any one of the 10 and they don’t feel the same as real aveilim, but still, there is a din of nihugei aveilus.

R’ Akiva Eiger in Y.D. 388 has a safeik in the case of someone who became an aveil on Y”T, in which case the aveilus is pushed off until after the Y”T ends, whether the person wear tefillin on the first day he observes aveilus post-Y"T.  The way the Rav understood the safeik (though see R”AKE inside) is whether the issur of tefillin is a din in the shem aveil, which sets in immediately on Y”T, or whether it is a din in nihugei aveilus, in which case it would not apply until mourning is actually practices, the first day after Y"T. 

Assuming the ptur of tefillin only applies where there is a shem aveil, we understand why it does not come into play on Tisha b’Av.  We practice nihugei aveilus, but there is no shem aveil on aveilus yeshana – it simply does not have the same effect on us.  We mourn, but it is a mourning of a historical event, not a mourning of tragedy fresh before us. 
 
We still have a day before the dast, so let us hope that Tisha b'Av this year will become a day of sason v'simcha, and our kinos will be transformed into a true tikun (Likutei Moharan 247 -- can I quote that in the same breath as the Rav's torah?  : ) 

Friday, July 12, 2013

isho m'shum chitzo and the date of Tisha b'Av

R’ Yochanan said (Ta’anis 29) that had he been present when the date of the tzom commemorating the churban was fixed, he would have set it on 10 Av, when most of the burning of the Mikdash took place, rather than on 9 Av, when the fire was started. 
 
Achronim ask: There is a machlokes R’ Yochanan and Reish Lakish (Baba Kamma 21) whether isho m’shum chitzav or isho m’shum mamono, whether an arsonist is liable because lighting a fire is like shooting an arrow at something, or whether he is liable because lighting a fire is like letting an ox destroy someone else’s property.  The Nimukei Yosef is mechadesh that according to R’ Yochanan, who holds isho m’shum chitzo, it is not at the moment the fire destroys (or the moment the arrow strikes its target) that the person becomes chayav, but rather it is from the moment the fire is lit (or the moment the arrow is released).  It is the setting in motion of the process which is key (we discussed this a few years ago).

If so, R’ Yochanan l’shitaso who holds isho m’shum chitzo should also hold that the 9th of Av, when the fire was lit, is the key moment from which all else follows.  Why did he think the fast should be on the 10th?

The Avnei Nezer answers that it is only with respect to the hischayvus of the individual that we look at the moment of the fire being lit; it is that moment which defines the individual as a poel, an actor, in the events that play out.  However, when looking at the consequences of the events themselves, of course what occurs later may be far more significant than the initial moment.

The She’eiris Menachem quotes another interesting answer (he does not attribute it, though he says he heard it from someone).  The Nimukei Yosef writes that just like you can’t pull an arrow back midflight, so too, what happens after a fire is lit is outside a person’s control -- liability occurs only for that first moment when a person has the ability to determine whether to strike the match or not or whether to release the arrow or not.
 
The gemara records that Hashem promised that just as He destroyed the Mikdash with fire, so too will He ultimately rebuild it with fire –- Hashem attributes the fire of destruction to himself, kavyachol. 
 
A human being may not be able to pull an arrow back midflight, or stop a fire once it has been lit, but nothing is outside Hashem’s power.  It is only when speaking of human action that we need to limit our focus to the first moment alone.  When speaking about G-d, the entire process can be taken into consideration.

erasing failure

The Sefas Emes in Parshas VaYechi writes that the fact that the parsha is stuma is not a symbolic reflection of the fact that Ya’akov’s attempt to foresee the geulah was blocked or that Klal Yisrael was being blocked in by the galus.  The parsha being stuma is the cause of that block.  Torah does not reflect what happens in reality; reality reflects things as they appear in Torah.

The first Rashi in Devarim tells us that Moshe Rabeinu only alluded to Klal Yisrael’s history of rebelliousness instead of openly giving them rebuke because he wanted to preserve their sense of dignity.  “Satam es ha’devarim,” Moshe sealed up his words and did not spell out the people’s shortcomings.  R’ Yechiel Michel Feinstein explains here as well that this is not just a rhetorical or literary device.  Words of Torah create reality.  By not speaking of the people’s failures, the effects to those failures is tempered; they are only b’derech remez part of our history, but otherwise no longer exist.

Thursday, July 11, 2013

coffee on 9 Av

Psak of R' Eliezer Melamed (link) for those of us who can't live without coffee:

שאלה: אני רגיל לשתות בכל יום כמה כוסות קפה, לכן בצומות כשאיני שותה קפה כואב לי הראש מאוד. האם יש פתרון לכך? ואולי אני נחשב כחולה שפטור מהצום?

תשובה: מכיוון שאתה זקוק לקפה כדי למנוע כאבי ראש, מותר לך לקחת קפה נמס או מגורען בכפית ולבלוע את הקפה בלא מים. וזאת משום שבאופן זה הקפה אינו ראוי לאכילה, שכן הוא מאוד לא טעים, ואף מעורר סלידה. ואמנם גם דברים שאינם ראויים לאכילה אסור לאכול בצומות, מפני שבזה שהאדם החליט לאוכלם, הרי שהוא החשיב אותם כמאכלים (רא"ש). אולם כאן, שהמטרה היא להסיר כאבי ראש, אין האדם שבולע את הקפה מחשיב אותו כאוכל אלא כתרופה. ומותר ליטול במשך היום מספר כפיות לפי הצורך.
 
עצה טובה: כדאי לצחצח אחר כך היטב את השיניים, כדי למנוע ריח רע מהפה.

ומי שיכול ישיג לעצמו כדורי אקמול עם קפאין, שנועדו למטרה זו, ויבלע אותם בצום בלי מים ובכך ימנע מעצמו כאבי ראש.

the nechama of "ki im ma'os m'astanu, katzafta aleinu ad me'od"

The connection between the last two pesukim of Eicha perplexes some of the meforshim:

Hashiveinu Hashem eilecha v’nashuva, chadeish yamainu k’kedem – Hashem, take us back and return things as they were in the good ol’ days. 

Ki im ma’os m’astanu, katzafta aleinu ad me’od – Because (?) you have made us repulsive to you, and been very angry at us. 

That word “ki,” which I translated as “because,” doesn’t quite fit, as Hashem’s anger would seem to be a very good reason for him NOT to take us back.  Does it mean that Hashem has expended his anger already, and therefore he should take us back?  Why should that be true if we haven’t done teshuvah yet?  Does it mean that our feeling Hashem’s anger is itself rehabilitative?  If so, the subject of the pasuk should be us, our feeling of suffering, not Hashem’s anger. 

We get very scared when we read that last pasuk of “ma’os m’astan, katazfta aleinu…,” so much so that we repeat the pasuk of “hashiveinu…” again right after it to end on a positive note.  But, explains the Berdichiver, this last pasuk is not a lament, it’s not there to make us scared -– it’s part of the nechama.  He gives a mashal from hilchos geirushin: if a man divorces his wife because of a problem of arayos, he is never allowed to remarry her – there is an issur on both the ba’al and the bo’el.  But if a man divorces his wife because she burnt his food and he got angry at her, he can always remarry her again.  After five perakim of Eicha a person might feel so crushed that they think any reconciliation with Hashem is impossible.  How can there be a “hashiveinu…” after all that?  Our running after strange gods is like a national issur arayos!  The answer is because “ma’os m’astanu, katzafta aleinu…”  It's not like arayos; it's not a permanent break.  Hashem is ineed very angry, but anger can pass; the door is open to reconciliation and is not glued shut.

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

9 Av as a moed

Chasam Sofer asks: When 9 Av falls on Shabbos, why does 10 Av, the day of the fast, have dinim that relate to it being a “moed?”  Lichorah, it is just the fasting which is pushed off until Sunday because it is impossible to fast on Shabbos, but the din “moed” can be celebrated on Shabbos and therefore should not come into play on the 10th.

Tuesday, July 09, 2013

chareidi autonomy from the state -- what agreement?

As reported here, R' Ahron Feldman, Rosh Yeshiva of Ner Yisrael, said the following in a recent speech about the situation in Israel:
Some Jews chose not to back the state. Our Gedolim felt that they could join with the state, on condition that they be granted autonomy. They would have their own education system, and other autonomous rights. This was the basis of the status quo agreement.
I'm curious: which gedolim is he is referring to when he says "our Gedolim" and what agreement (which apparently the state, at least in his view, was a willing party to) is he talking about?   Can someone point me to anything in writing from chareidi gedolim that would indicate an acceptance of zionism in exchange for a quid pro quo acceptance of charedi autonomy in certain areas?  Excuse my ignorance if this is something everyone knows about except me.

Simply as a matter of government/politics, for a democratic state to grant autonomous rights to a select group of citizens would be pretty remarkable.

As for the rest of the speech -- it's not worth dissecting.  I've abandoned all hope of understanding the arguments and rhetoric of the chareidi world.  I don't think anyone not already drinking the kool-aid is convinced by these speeches, and that's probably not the goal anyway -- it's probably just to rally those already on board.

Update: Daniel commented that R' Feldman was referring to Ben Gurion's letter of 1947.  Only problem is Ben Gurion's letter specifically says, "The state will naturally determine the minimum requirement of compulsory studies in Hebrew language, history, science, and so forth, and will supervise this minimum."  So I'm still confused as to why R' Feldman would start with this point, but what do I know.

Monday, July 08, 2013

R' Soloveitchik: "bnei beischa k'vatchila" on shalosh regalim = the tune of "Ali Tzion"

I found something I never heard before in the name of the Rav quoted by R’ Ya’akov Shapira in one of his ma’amarim on the parsha (link). 

הרב סולווצ'יק אמר פעם, תמיד בג' רגלים שמגיעים לבקשה על המקדש, בנה ביתך כבתחילה מי שהוא זוכר את המנגינה, של זה? אני לא שומע? זה בדיוק אותה מנגיה של עלי ציון ועליה, אין מציאות להזכיר את המקדש לבי לשתף את הצער על חרבן הבית אמת לאמיתה

The melody we use in musaf for shalosh regalim for the words "bnei beischa k'vatchila" matches the melody we use at the end of kinos for "Ali tzion."  (I'll leave it to your ear to make up its own mind.)  RYBS explained that it is impossible to mention the Mikdash without also giving expression to the sorrow and pain caused by its destruction. 

I have heard "lomdus" in RYBS's name on various points in the nusach hatefilah, but here he is saying "lomdus" even on the tune!

Parenthetically, if you have never read R' Ya'akov Shapira's stuff (the ma'amarim on the parshiyos go back about 3 years on the Merkaz haRav site), you are missing out on absolutely wonderful Torah that I don't think you can find the equal of in many other places. 

Update: I don't know if he also got it from the Rav, but Cantor Bernard Beer makes the same point here (at about the 2:20 mark).

Friday, July 05, 2013

targum even for Ataros and Divon

A few years ago we discussed the gemara (Brachos 8) that a person has to finish shenayim mikra v’echad targum with the tzibur, even the pasuk of Ataros v’Divon (32:3) mentioned in our parsha.  Why does the gemara single out this pasuk?  Rashi explains that these are just place names; the targum adds no interpretation.  The gemara therefore streeses that these pesukim must be read as well; one must read the mikra three times since there is no targum.

Tosfos asks: if Rashi is right, the gemara could have chosen any pasuk that simply lists names.  Why these in particular?  Tosfos therefore suggests that the pasuk of Ataros v’Divon was chosed because there is a Targum Yerushalmi on the pasuk.  Even though this targum is not the “standard” targum of Onkelus, it is still better than just reading the mikra three times.

I saw this year that Rabeinu Bachyei offers a different answer.  Rashi 32:38 writes with respect to the cities of Nevo and Ba’al Me’on that these names were associated with idolatry.  When the cities were conquered by Reuvain, they changed the names to something else. Rabeinu Bachyei extends this idea to the names of all nine cities mentioned, including Ataros and Divon.  One might have thought that since reading the targum here involves reciting names of avodah zarah it should be omitted; therefore, the gemara stresses that even here there is a chiyuv to read shenayim mikra v’echad targum.

gilu b're'ada

The gemara learns from “isha hafeiram v’Hashem yislach lah” that even though a woman’s husband was matir her neder before she violated it, so in truth she did nothing wrong because the neder she violated no longer exists, she still needs slicha and kaparah.  R’ Akiva moralized: if kapprah is needed even for someone who intended to do an issur but in fact did nothing wrong, think of how serious the consequences are for someone who intended to do wrong and carries out the deed!

The Mishna tells us that the two happiest days of the year were Yom Kippur and 15 Av.  Let’s put aside 15 Av for now and focus on Yom Kippur.  Why was it one of the happiest days?  The gemara explains because it is the day of slicha and kapprah.  Slicha and kapparah is a reason to rejoice; we should be dancing on Yom Kippur like on Simchas Torah!  Contrast that with R’ Akiva’s reaction to our pasuk of “v’Hashem yislach lah.”  You would think that this woman who narrowly escaped doing an aveira and is promised slicha v’kaprah should be rejoicing, yet R’ Akiva tosses cold water all over the celebration and tells us that she should be quaking in her boots, kal v’chomer someone who really sins.

Perhaps there is no contradiction here, but two sides of the same coin.  The celebration of slicha and kapprah stems davka from the appreciation of just how precarious the situation one who needs slicha is in.

Wednesday, July 03, 2013

a question of priorities

There were three cities of refuge in Eiver haYarden alone and another three for all of Eretz Yisrael.  It seems that that Eiver haYarden had a disproportionate share of murderers compared with the rest of Eretz Yisrael.  I heard an interesting thought from R' Meir Goldvicht as to why this should have been the case.  Bnei Reuvain and Gad made a deal with Moshe.  They told Moshe that they will leave behind their cattle, their wives and children, and lead the rest of Bnei Yisrael in battle on the condition that they can have the land of Eiver haYarden.  When he accepted the deal, Moshe corrected one thing they said.  He told them to build cities for their wives and children and a place for their cattle -- a home for their children is the first priority, cattle second.  Although Bnei Reuvan and Gad got the message that their children's needs were paramount, the fact is that for the long campaign of the conquest of Eretz Yisrael their children grew up with no fathers.  Most of the male population served as soliders and there was no one home to help raise families.  As a result, the society of Eiver haYarden was tainted in a way that other communities were not.

Nedarim 22 records that Ula witnessed the murder of one of his travelling companions en route to Eretz Yisrael.  The gemara asks how this could be -- the pasuk of "v'nasan Hashem lecha shem lev ragaz" applies to Bavel, not Eretz Yisrael.  The gemara answers that the murder happened before they had crossed the Yarden.  It seems from this gemara that there is a segulah aspect to Eretz Yisrael not being a land in which murder occurs.

Tuesday, July 02, 2013

the Cyrus Cylinder at the Met

On Sunday I took advantage of the opportunity to see the Cyrus Cylinder, which is on loan from the British Museum at the Met for a limited time.  The cylinder is a cuneiform inscription of an announcement made by Cyrus, i.e. Koresh, upon his conquest of Bavel allowing subjugated people to return to their homelands and resume their own form of worship.  Not mentioned explicitly, but thought to be part and parcel of this same policy, is Koresh’s granting of permission to the Jewish people to return to Eretz Yisrael and rebuild the Mikdash.  As the website devoted to the Cylinder puts it, “To Jewish people the story told by the Cyrus Cylinder is a magnificent one, as it corroborates the events in the Old Testament about King Cyrus allowing captive Jews to return to Jerusalem and rebuild their temple. In fact, in the book of Ezra, King Cyrus permits the Jewish exiled people to return to Jerusalem to rebuild the temple.”  What better time than the Three Weeks to see an artifact like this.  

The Cylinder is on tour in the US and will be at other museums in other cities.  The website has more information here.  What surprised me is just how small the Cylinder is (I did not see the website in advance) -- it’s shape and size reminded me of the pressed-wood logs we use in the fireplace in the winter.  It makes the discovery even more impressive.

A few small tips for visiting the Met, which you may know already: Do not be put off by the suggested admission price.  If you can afford $25 a person, good for you.  If not, go anyway.  Plenty of people just give what they can and the admissions desk will give you no grief.  It’s worth the trip.  Also, try to get there early because especially on weekends, the museum gets plenty crowded.  Finally, do not attempt to bring a picnic lunch into the museum with you.  The guards are very strict about allowing food inside.  Your best bet is to check your bag when you enter and then go out to the park and eat there. 

Friday, June 28, 2013

give Yehoshua a hand -- or two

As part of the process of transferring power to Yehoshua, Hashem told Moshe “v’samachta es yadcha alav,” (27:18) to lay his hand, singular, upon Yehoshua.    However, when Moshe carried out Hashem’s command it says “va’yismoch yadav alav,” (27:23) he lay his hands, plural, on Yehoshua.  Rashi explains that Moshe wanted to give Yehoshua what he could “b’ayin yafeh,” with good measure, so he went above and beyond what Hashem commanded and used both his hands.

The Kli Yakar asks how is it that Moshe could deviate from what Hashem commanded – isn’t there an issur of bal tosif?  I don’t understand his question.  The issur of bal tosif is to change a mitzvah.  “V’samach yadcha” is nowhere counted as one of the 613 mitzvos, so what's the problem?

(R’ Shteinman in his Ayeles haShachar here answers the question by distinguishing between a command given to an individual and a command given to all of Klal Yisrael.  It seems to me that his chiluk focusses on the symptom but not the root cause.  Something told to the individual is by definition not a mitzvah –- that’s why there is no bal tosif.  The size of the audience is just a siman, not the driving force.)

Secondly, adding to what Hashem says is not always bal tosif.  If I eat more than a k’zayis of matzah on Pesach night, obviously there is no problem of bal tosif.  The shiur is a minimum kiyum, not a maximum limit.  So too here, Rashi’s borrowing of the term “b’ayin yafeh” from the world of commerce in Baba Basra or from the world of hafrashas terumah indicates that we are dealing with adding something above and beyond the minimum requirement, not passing a maximum threshold.

So much for the technical details; now let’s get to the crux of what’s going on: what difference does it really make whether Moshe put one hand on Yehoshua’s head or two?

The Shem m’Shmuel suggests that Moshe understood that the next generation, the generation that would conquer Eretz Yisrael, would need two types of leadership: 1) military/political/social/economic leadership to build and run the country; 2) spiritual leadership to continue the mesorah of Torah.  (See the Derashos haRan on Parshas Shoftim.)

Hashem told Moshe “v’samach yadcha,” place one of your hands on Yehoshua – give him one of those two elements of leadership.  Let him wage war, let him become the Prime Minister and figure out how to build the country.  However, “lifnei Elazar hakohen ya’amod,” let him defer to Elazer in spiritual matters.  Even without the daf yomi, the Shem m’Shmuel remembered Rashi in Eiruvin 63b that explains this pasuk to mean that Yehoshua would have to ask questions of halacha to Elazar.  Elazar, not Yehoshua, would be the “ba’al hamesorah,” the leader responsible for the transmission of Torah to the next generation, and in this way something of Moshe’s legacy would remain for his family, the kohanim, who would be the primary teachers of Torah (see Rashi 27:23).

Moshe Rabeinu, however, decided to give both aspects of leadership to his talmid Yehoshu; he placed both his hands on his head.  Not only was Yehoshua the great general who conquered Eretz Yisrael, but as we know from the first Mishna in Pirkei Avos, Yehoshua was the next link in the chain of mesorah of Torah as well.

This was not done for Yehoshua’s benefit alone, writes the Shem m’Shmuel, but also for the benefit of Klal Yisrael.  By combining both roles in one individual, Moshe ensured that the political/economic/social development of Eretz Yisrael would be inseperable from and intertwined with Torah.

Need I spell out the lesson for our times where Torah leaders want no part in being generals and generals don’t want to hear about Torah?  Where the seperation between Torah scholarship and service to Eretz Yisrael is seen as an ideal rather than a failure to have an integrated whole? 

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

chiyuv ta'anis -- m'divrei kabbalah or based on minhag?

The Rambam opens Hil Ta'anis by telling us:
 יש שם ימים שכל ישראל מתענים בהם

He then lists all the fast days and tells us what happened on each of them.  In halacha 5 he writes:
 וארבעת ימי הצומות האלו--הרי הן מפורשין בקבלה

What's important is what the Rambam does NOT say -- he never writes that there is a chiyuv m'divrei kabbalah to fast on any of these days, even on 9 Av!  The fasts are described, "mefurashim," in divrei kabbalah, i.e. Nach, but the chiyuv to fast is simply based on minhag yisrael and no more than that. 

Contrast that with the language of the Tur, "Hakol chayavim l'hisanos m'DIVREI KABBALAH..."  True, the Tur quotes the gemara that when there is no shmad the chiyuv to fast depends on the ratzon of Bnei Yisrael, but it seems that according to the Tur the idea of ratzon is not a mechayeiv (which is how the Rambam must have learned the gemara), but is just an acceptance of the chiyuv that already exists m'divrei kabbalah.

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

ki tov b'einei Hashem l'vareich es Yisrael -- a bracha of the eyes and how to earn it

Continuing the theme from last week’s post on the topic of seeing as it relates to Tamuz and parshas Balak, I want to point out a piece in the Radomsker that I saw over Shabbos.  “Va’yar Bilam ki tov b’einei Hashem l’vareich es Yisrael… “(24:1) Bilam saw that it was good in the eyes of Hashem (there’s that word “eyes” again) to bless Bnei Yisrael, so he gave up any pretense of trying to curse them and instead gave a bracha.  The Radomsker asks the obvious: Bilam knew from the moment he left his house, or certainly from the moment his donkey began to speak and he saw the angel blocking his path on the road, that Hashem was not going to let him curse Bnei Yisrael.  Why does the pasuk make it sound like there was some new revelation here, that suddenly only now Bilam saw that Hashem wanted to only bless Bnei Yisrael? 

The Radomsker teaches that there are two types of brachos.  Bracha cam be transmitted by the laying of hands upon the recipient, e.g. when Ya’akov blessed Ephraim and Menashe, he placed his hands upon them; when the kohanim bless us, it is through nesi’as kapayim, raising their hands.  Bracha can also be transferred by sight, e.g. “kol makom she’nasnu chachamim eineihem…” the gemara tells us that whatever the Chachamim set their sights on with good intent they delivered bracha (they can do the opposite as well).

When the Mishkan was completed, the Torah tells us that after his first avodah, “Va'yisa Aharon es yadav el ha’am vayivarchem,” Aharon lifted his hands and blessed Bnei Yisrael (Vayikra 9:22).  Moshe, however, gave his bracha by gazing at the work Bnei Yisrael had done, “Va’yar Moshe es kol ha’melacha… va'yivarech osam Moshe” (Shmos 39:43).  Again, we have bracha delivered through hands and bracha delivered through sight.

Let’s try to translate the mystical jargon into something meaningful for us.  A lot of times someone will come over and ask for a favor and in your heart and mind you could care less about the person’s needs or you are not really in the mood to listen to their tzaros, but you do the favor anyway because that’s the fastest way to get rid of the person.  On a little higher madreiga, someone asks for a favor and you really don’t want to be involved, but you know you owe them one (or you want them to owe you one), so you take care of it.  A little higher madreiga, you feel a moral obligation to respond when someone needs help – here too, it’s not about the other person per se, but it’s about your need to quell your conscience.  In all of these cases, make no mistake about it, you are doing the other person a favor, but it’s a bracha that comes only from the hands -- it's a utilitarian response.  The heart and mind have not been touched by the person’s story or the person’s needs. 

Then there is the rare case when someone comes to ask for a favor and you really feel their need and you empathize with their plight.  When you respond, the action taken is not just a means to an end, a way to get them off your back or get the problem out of the way, but rather is because you can genuinely identify with the person’s plight.  The ability to see other people in that way, apart from the action taken, is itself a bracha.

Bracha delivered though the eyes, explains the Radomsker, is vastly greater than bracha delivered though the hands alone.  We ask Hashem every day that it should be “tov b’einecha l’vareich es Yisrael…” good in his eyes to give us bracha.  We don’t just want Hashem to do us favors, we want him to look at us with love and empathy and give us bracha in that way. 

Bilam knew that Hashem was only interested in blessing Bnei Yisrael, but he did not realize the full extent of what that meant.  It is only after time and again that his attempt to muster any type of curse was thwarted that he realized that Hashem’s bracha for Bnei Yisrael is that special type of “Va’yar ki tov b’einei Hashem l’vareich es Yisrael,” the bracha that comes through seeing us in that special way.

How were Bnei Yisrael zocheh to this special bracha?  Because “v’kisah es ein ha’aretz,” their physical eyes, as we discussed last post, were closed.  Because, as Rashi writes on “mah tovu ohalecha,” their tent doors were turned away from each other; no one looked inside another person’s tent and intruded on their privacy.  People kept their eyes to themselves, v’ain kan makom l’ha’arich on the obvious lessons.  Midah k’neged midah, if we use our eyes properly, Hashem will respond in kind with “tov b’einei Hashem l’vareich es Yisrael…”

Monday, June 24, 2013

why did Hashem want to silence Bilam?

Sticks and stones may break my bones but words can never harm me…  so why did Hashem need to stop Bilam?  Who cares if he says anything?

One approach, which we’ve done in the past (also here), is that words indeed can cause harm.  We may not understand how it works, we may no longer be able to use such power, but Hashem built into the teva such a phenomenon.  This seems to fit the simple reading of Chazal that Bilam knew the moment of Hashem's anger and could summon a curse in that precise moment (Hashem, however, did a chessed and did not show any answer while Bilam was trying to do his thing.)  Think of it this way: if you were to show someone in the ancient world a gun, they would have no idea how it worked either and would think of it as a magical device (brings back memories of A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court).  We can think of the idea of using words to cause harm in the same way (Ohr haChaim, Ralbag at the end of to'eles 6).

I think it may be a bit hard to convince modern readers that words can kill.  Some other reasons Hashem stopped Bilam from cursing Bnei Yisrael:

1)    Hashem wanted to stop Bilam so that Bilam would not be guilty of wrongdoing (Seforno 22:22.  This begs the question of why Hashem should care so much about Bilam’s fate – let him sin and get the punishment he deserves?)

2)    Had Bilam cursed Bnei Yisrael, every time Bnei Yisrael did wrong and were punished, the enemies of Bnei Yisrael would give credence to Bilam’s curses rather than attribute the punishment to Bnei Yisrael’s wrongdoing (Ralbag mentions this idea and rejects it).  This is akin to Moshe’s argument in response to the cheit ha’eigel of of “lamah yomru Mitrayim…,” that the nations will attribute Bnei Yisrael’s downfall to Hashem’s lack of power c”v, not to their wrongdoing.

3)    Had Bilam cursed Bnei Yisrael, it would make it very difficult for Bnei Yisrael to do teshuvah.  Whenever they sinned and were punished by Hashem, rather than attribute punishment to their misbehavior, they would attribute it to Bilam’s curses.  (Ralbag accepts this theory over the previous one, as it better fits Malachi’s description of Hashem's stopping Bilam being a chessed for Bnei Yisrael.)

4)    Bilam’s curses would embolden the enemies of Bnei Yisrael to attack because they would perceive or assume that his curses have some effect even if in truth they cause no harm (Meshech Chochma). 

Thursday, June 20, 2013

ki ayin b'ayin yiru b'shuv Hashem Tzion -- learning how to see

I think a little background is needed to really get the torah of the Sefas Emes on this week’s parsha:

“Vatipackahna einei she’neyhem…”  After their sin, the Torah tells us that Adam and Chavah’s eyes were opened and they were embarrassed by their own nakedness.  Surely Adam and Chavah did not walk around with their eyes closed beforehand –- why didn’t the pasuk just tell us that they were embarrassed, they attained a different type of knowledge, etc.  What does it mean to say that their eyes were opened? 

The Chasam Sofer quotes his rebbe, the Hafla’ah, as explaining that we have two sets of eyes: we have physical outer eyes that we are all used to using, but we also have an inner set of eyes, ruchniyus-dik eyes, that allow us to see inner spiritual pnimiyus of the world.  Depending on which set of eyes you use to view the world, you end up seeing a very different place.

The catch is that when choosing which eyes to use, it’s an either/or option.  If our inner, ruchniyus eyes are open and we use those eyes to see the world, our outer eyes must remain closed.  If we choose to use those outer physical eyes and see physical and materialistic things, the inner eye that is sensitive to ruchniyus will squint and close.

Adam and Chavah were created to use their inner, spiritual eyes to see the world.  Sin caused those eyes to close, and at the same time, "vatipacahna einei she’neyhem,” their physical eyes were opened, and the world has never looked the same since.

The twelve months of the year correspond to the twelve shevatim.  According to one view, the order starts with Nisan and sheivet Yehudah and follows the order of the degalim in the midbar.  The month of Tamuz corresponds to the fourth sheivet in the degalim, the tribe of Reuvain.  Reuvain’s name comes from Leah’s saying, “Ra’ah Hashem is onyi,” Hashem saw my pain.  The month of Tamuz, the month of Reuvain, explains the Bnei Yisascher at length, is all about what we see and how we see.

The meraglim, who Moshe sent to go see the land, came back during Tamuz and gave their report.  The mefoshim struggle to discover exactly where they sinned – it seems that every word in their report was true.  And indeed it was – so long as the land was looked at only with the outer eyes.  “V’n’hi b’eineinu k’chagavim, v’kein hayinu b’eineihem,” “We were in our eyes like grasshoppers, and so we were in their eyes.” (13:33)  What eyes in the Torah talking about?  Surely not the inner eyes of ruchniyus.  The error of the spies was in closing those inner eyes and instead seeing the world only through the outer eyes, the eyes that see only see the physical, materialistic world.  What a scary and false picture they saw when they looked at Eretz Yisrael only with those eyes!  They never saw the true picture, the picture you can see only if you close those outer eyes and open the inner ones.

And now we can get to the Sefas Emes.  In our parsha, Bnei Yisrael are on the right track again, headed to Eretz Yisrael.  Balak hires Bilam to stop them (see Shem m’Shmuel).  He reports that Bnei Yisrael are encroaching on his territory, “Vayichas es ein ha’aretz,” they covered the "eye of the land."  What a strange expression!  Here’s the Sefas Emes’ explanation (first piece in 5632), and it’s worth getting it word for word – “Hi histaklus artziyus, she’Bnei Yisrael hei’iru l’hiyos ha’reiya rak el ha’pnimiyus b’kol davar, u’lvateil histaklus chitzoni, mah she’nireh lichoreh b’ein gashmi…”  Bnei Yisrael covered the “ein artziyus,” the physical eye, the eye that only sees the superficial, the eye that sees only the material world, and they opened their eyes to the pnimiyus in everything around them (the S.A. has a number of pieces on the parsha that are variations on this theme).  Balak was saying, "They just don’t see things the way we do.  We don’t see eye to eye with them."

The Midrash comments that it would be better if the wicked were blind, as we find so often evil associated with their seeing – “VaYiru Bnei Elokim…” (Braishis 6), “Va’yar Cham avi Kena’an…” (Brashis 9), “Vayiru osah sarei Pharoah…” (Braishis 12), and finally our parsha, “Va’yar Balak…”  When you see with the outside eyes, bad things are bound to follow. 

Bilam is described as "s'sum ha'ayim," which according to some means blind in one eye, but according to the Targum means he was able to see well. Perhaps both may be true: Bilam, the navi of the umos, was partially blind to the outside world, and as a result, his inner eye was open to see what others could not.

Perhaps this explains why, as Rashi explains, Bilam is told that he will never overcome Bnei Yisrael, as they celebrate the three regalim.  Why is is specifically the mitzvah of celebrating the regalim that thwarts Bilam?  Because the mitzvah of aliya la'regel involves coming "lei'raos lifnei Hashem," to be seen by Hashem, and as Chazal teach us, a person comes to the Mikdash to see as much as he comes to be seen.  Aliya la'regel is all about absorbing a vision of kedusha, and that is what Bilam was blind to.

So we have to learn to see the world in the right way.  We have to learn to use our inner eyes more and close the outer eyes that give us the wrong messages.  We have to open the eyes, the real eyes, of the world.  If we do that, instead of Tamuz being the start of three weeks marking churban, we will merit to see “ain b’ayin yiru b’shuv Hashem Tzion…”  (Yeshayahu 52).  To return to the Hafla’ah we started with, he asks what “ayin b’ayin” means – we don’t have eyes within our eyes, do we?  The answer is that yes, we do – these are the inner spiritual eyes that are deep within us, behind the physical eyes that give us our vision.  I saw a horrible letter to the editor of a Jewish newspaper last week asking why we would want to live in Eretz Yisrael with all the problems that are there.  That’s what happens when you look at things with the outer eye only.  If only that person would open their real eyes, the one’s inside, they would see the tremendous beauty of Eretz Yisrael and the process of geulah that is already underway.  If we start seeing “ayin b’ayin,” then we will surely see “b’shuv Hashem Tzion.”

mission accomplished

Earlier this week I posted my wife’s question of why Miriam died in the midbar and was prevented from reaching Eretz Yisrael.  The Torah tells us that Moshe and Aharon did not make it because they sinned at Mei Meriva, but the Torah offers no similar explanation for Miriam not making it.

You might argue (see the comments to that post) that the question should not get off the ground.  Miriam was by this point well advanced in years.  Do we need a justification for her death?  No one lives forever.  Maybe Miriam deserved to get to Eretz Yisrael, but nebech, she just passed away before getting there.  I thought a reply to that point deserved it's own post.

The Sefas Emes (5639, see here) says a yesod in last week’s parsha: Death = your task in the world is complete.  Every person has a tikun to accomplish, and once the tikun is accomplished, you move on.  It’s like a video game – when all the monsters are killed in one level, you move on to the next.

Aharon is told he must die because he sinned and could not enter Eretz Yisrael.  So what, asks the Sefas Emes?  Bnei Yisrael were not on the border of Eretz Yisrael yet -– maybe Aharon had a few more days or weeks left in him?  The answer is that Aharon already had accomplished everything he could in this world short of being mekayeim mitzvos of Eretz Yisrael.  If those mitzvos had been part of his mission – which they would have been had he not sinned – he would have continued to live.  Since those mitzvos were no longer on the agenda, his mission was up, and m’meila his time was up.

What we can accomplish in this world is not dependent upon how much time we are allotted to be here – aderaba, how much time we are allotted to be here depends on what we can accomplish.  It makes no sense to say Miriam really deserved to get to Eretz Yisrael but nebech, her time was up.  If Miriam had the zechuyos that would allow her to be in Eretz Yisrael, her mission was not over yet, and m'meila her time in this world would not have ended yet.

If you saw the update to the previous post, you saw the link to the Midrash’s answers to the question of why Miriam died.  One answer is that her well had to vanish, which could not happen so long as she was alive.  I thought this put the cart before the horse – the well vanished, I thought, because Miriam died; not that Miriam died so that the well could vanish.  My wife thought the Midrash means to tell us that the miraculous hanhaga of the midbar had to come to an end before Bnei Yisrael entered Eretz Yisrael.  The miracle of getting water from Miriam’s well could not continue; in Eretz Yisrael, water would have to be drawn from rivers, means of irrigation would have to be developed,etc.  Therefore, Miriam had to die so that Bnei Yisrael could come down to earth, so to speak, and continue their mission in Eretz Yisrael, albeit without her. 

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

cutting it short

I am not sure at what age wearing shorts stops being cute, but it happens.  It hasn’t even been really hot here yet, but already I see teens and even adults showing up to davening wearing shorts and T-shirts.  B’shlama not wearing a hat, I understand – hats are out of fashion (at least in society at large), so not wearing one is the social norm.  But people do still wear pants, shirts with collars and buttons, jackets, etc.  In my workplace, which is business casual, they recently sent out a reminder e-mail about what is acceptable dress and what isn’t, and shorts and a T-shirt is definitely on the not-acceptable list.  If it’s not acceptable in a business casual office environment, what’s the hava amina that it is acceptable when standing before G-d?

Even in camp, where someone may rush in from the ballfield to catch a mincha, I wonder whether or not it might be better to miss minyan and take the time to change.  Who says that tefilah b’tzibur outweighs tefilah dressed appropriately?  I haven’t looked it up, but at least off the cuff it doesn’t strike me as an absurd question.
 
Even if you personally don’t care if you come to daven looking like a shlump, it sets a certain tone in a minyan when enough people do it.  It makes a statement: “We’re not formal here – sit back and relax, make yourself comfortable…”  My parents told me recently of a shul in their neighborhood where people come in (I am talking about the room used for davening, not the lobby) on Shabbos carrying coffee cups, pushing strollers, etc.  They feel at home; they are as comfortable in shul as they are in the privacy of their living room or lounging at Starbucks.  I don’t know about you, but “Da lifnei mi atah omeid,” doesn’t sound to me like we are supposed to feel all that comfortable.

The problem, of course, is that blog posts on the topic will change nothing.  Matzah min es mino – people who treat davening a certain way will go to daven with other people who treat davening the same way, creating a spiral that reinforces itself.  Those who agree with this post most likely do not come to daven in shorts and a T-shirt and most likely daven in places where such a thing would be an aberration; those who disagree probably think I’m a fanatic (which may be true anyway…)  The question is how to change the culture once certain norms become institutionalized.  I have no idea of the answer.

We're coming up to the three weeks, the time to mourn churban habayis.  Does anyone think it would be appropriate the show up to the mikdash wearing shorts and a T-shirt, sipping a coffee?  Of course not.  So why treat the mikdash me'at in our communities any differently?

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

the death of Aharon and Miriam

Why does the Torah need to tell us that Hor HaHar, the burial place of Aharon, was on the border of the land of Edom?  Rashi (20:23) explains that it was because Bnei Yisrael drew close to Edom that they lost Aharon.

All Bnei Yisrael did was ask Edom for passage through their lands, and since Edom did not grant permission, they were forced to circumnavigate their whole territory – what kind of contact was there that would cause the death of Aharon? 

The Shem m’Shmuel writes that the problem was the message sent to Edom (20:14), “Koh amar achicha Yisrael,” “This is what your brother Yisrael has to say…”  We are not brothers with Edom.  And while it is true that the navi Malachi says (1:3), “Ha’lo ach Eisav l’Ya’akov,” “Is not Eisav the brother of Ya’akov,” the navi is careful to use the name Yakaov, not the name Yisrael.  Biologically of course we are related to Eisav, but when we speak of ourselves as Yisrael, the name that alludes to our spiritual greatness, we need to recognize that we are alone and apart from all other people. 

Even though that message to Edom was sent by Moshe, and even though it was for the purpose of reminding Edom that as our brother they should have shared the burden of Egyptian slavery with us and therefore they owed us, there was still something wrong with it.

The Shem m’Shmuel does not spell out what the midah k’neged midah is here, so I just wanted to add my own two cents.  Aharon’s life work as a rodef shalom v’oheiv shalom was to increase achvah, brotherly love, within Klal Yisrael.  The use of the term “achicha,” brother, when speaking to a descendent of Eisav, proved that we did not fully appreciate what the value of true achvah is; we did not appreciate the value that Aharon dedicated his life to install in Klal Yisrael.  Therefore, Hashem took Aharon from us at that moment.

On another note, the episode of Mei Meriva gets so much attention in the meforshim that we almost forget that last week’s parsha tells us of Miriam’s death as well.  We know why Moshe and Aharon did not merit entering Eretz Yisrael; however, my wife pointed out, we are never told why Miriam died in the midbar.  Anyone have any ideas?

(Update: Here is an obscure Midrash quoted in the Torah Shleima that has an answer, but I am not sure what to make of it.)

Monday, June 17, 2013

the significance of the 9th of Tamuz

Yirmiyahu haNavi tells us (52:6-7) that on th 9th day of the 4th month, i.e. the 9th of Tamuz, that there was a great famine in Yerushalayim and the walls were finally breached.  So why do we fast on the 17th of Tamuz in commemoration of the walls being breached and not on the 9th? 

1) Tosfos (R"H 18b) explains that our fast on the 17th commemorates when the walls were breached during the destruction of the second Beis haMikdash; Yirmiyahu is speaking of the events surrounding the destruction of the first Mikdash.  To avoid making things too difficult (tircha d'tzibura), we fast only for the events of the second churban (Ramban).

2) The Yerushalmi explains that there was such confusion that occurred because of the destruction that Yirmiyahu recorded the wrong date.

The Magen Avraham (549:2) suggests a nafka minah between the answers.  According to Tosfos, if not for the consideration of tircha d'tzibura, the 9th of Tamuz should be a fast day.  Therefore, a ba'al nefesh who is able to fast should take upon him/herself to do so on that day.  According to the Yerushalmi, the 9th of Tamuz has no significance; it was only Yirmiyahu's error that even caused it to get a mention.

(One could argue that even for a ba'al nefesh there is no reason to fast on 9 Tamuz.  It's not that 9 Tamuz is a fast day but we all have an out because of the excuse of tircha -- rather, because it would be a tircha, there was never a takanah to fast on 9 Tamuz, only on 17 Tamuz.)

It is interesting that even according to the MG"A, it seems that a ba'al nefesh would only fast on 9 Tamuz, but the aveilus practices of the three weeks would start only on the 17th. 

It's strange that according to the Yerushalmi, sefer Yirmiyahu records for posterity the wrong date on which the walls were breached.  Even if Yirmiyahu erred because of the confusion of the moment, why would the sefer preserve the mistake?  Why not correct it?

The Maharasha (Ta'anis 28b) learns that there is no machlokes between the Bavli and Yerushalmi.  In reality, the churban even of Bayis Rishon took place on 17 Tamuz according to our calendar.  However, because the enemy had taken control and changed the calendar to their count, a solar calendar instead of a lunar one, the date of destruction was fixed according to their count as 9 Tamuz (take a look at how he explains why the discrepency is only 8 days -- I don't understand it).   Based on this approach, there is no error in the date of 9 Tamuz; it is correct according to the enemies calendar.

The Chasam Sofer in his derashos offers a different answer.  He writes that the breach of the walls did not occur in one moment, but was a slow process.  On the 9th of Tamuz, there was a small break in the walls.  Had Bnei Yisrael seized this final opportunity to do teshuvah, even with the enemy already beginning to penetrate the gates of the city, Yerushalayim would have been spared.  As we know, Bnei Yisrael did not do teshuvah, the walls grew weaker, the break greater, and finally on 17 Tamuz, the walls were completely breached.  According to the Yerushalmi, Yirmiyahu wanted to preserve the date of 9 Tamuz when the first weaking of the walls began because it was the failure to do teshuvah on that date that was really the final straw. 

The Lubavitcher Rebbe gives a similar answer and adds that we can take away from here an important lesson about the power of teshuvah.  Even though the city had been under siege for over two years and time and time again Bnei Yisrael had been warned to do teshuvah or face the consequences and had not heeded the message, Hashem still did not allow the breach of the walls to go through on the 9th of Tamuz, when it was deserved, but he held the enemy back for a few more days, lest Bnei Yisrael finally return.  Even at the precipice of disaster, even for those who have sqandered previous opportunities and are so very late to the game, teshuvah is still possible.

Friday, June 14, 2013

my son's yeshiva's siyum

In past years I have always written about the end of year siyum made in my son’s yeshiva, celebrated once again last Sunday when over 70 boys finished Mes. Kesubos, and this year for some reason I neglected to do so because of silly distractions.  This final siyum is just the grand finale; there were other siyumim during the year of boys who finished chazarah sedorim on masechtos for the second or third time (and even more than that).  The boys all deserve tremendous credit for their accomplishment. 

 As I’ve written before, the boys from the yeshiva are mostly local to our Five Towns/Far Rockaway community.  We have over half a dozen kosher pizza stores in the neighborhood, countless other eateries and places to waste time, I am sure the vast majority of homes have a computer with internet, the mesivta boys all have secular high school classes to attend and most boys go to college at some point -- in short, there is no shortage of potential distractions from learning, and yet the yeshiva somehow instills in the boys a drive to finish masechtos and learn with hasmadah.  That is no small feat.

Instead of writing about something the guest speaker said or something any of the hanhala said, as I’ve done in the past, I want to just mention something one of the boys said that I thought encapsulated what makes the yeshiva special.  This was I think a 12th grader who asked reshus from the menahel to speak for just a moment, and, on his own, took the opportunity to express hakaras hatov to all the older bachurim and kollel guys who put in countless hours not just to finish the masechta themselves, but also made time to help the younger guys who also wanted to finish.  He mentioned that just that morning a boy was not quite done with the masechta but wanted to be part of the siyum, so one of the older guys in the yeshiva spent the morning learning with him whatever blatt he needed to complete.

I don’t mean to take anything away from the Rebbeim, the Rosh Yeshiva, the hanhala, all of whom deserve credit for making the yeshiva work.  But a yeshiva is made of more than it’s staff and more than the walls of a building.  I would venture to say that the influence of peers is far greater than that of Rebbeim, Roshei Yeshiva, and maybe even of parents.  We are so used to speaking of the negative influence of peer pressure, but it works the other way as well.  What this 12th grader recognized (and had the good midos to express hakaras ha’tov for) is that what makes the yeshiva a success is the guy sitting next to him who he can ask a question to at night seder, the guy whose davening may inspire him, the guy like himself who he sees covering blatt after blatt in a difficult masechta and proves that it can be finished if you apply yourself.  It’s not just that the better or older guys in the yeshiva are there as passive role models to emulate – it’s that they reach out to others, they extend the invitation for a chavrusa, they extend the invitation to a discuss a difficult Tosfos, they are there just to talk to. 

Were this just the offhand remark of a 12th grader, I have to admit that being the cynical person that I am, I might dismiss it.  But I am in the yeshiva myself many nights of the week to learn for a bit and daven ma’ariv (and parenthetically, I am not the only one – there are other parents, alumni, people from the community who are sitting and learning.  Yeshiva is not just a place to dump your teenager in, but to be effective needs to be part of your life and your community’s life, but that’s a discussion for another time…) and I see the interactions first hand.  I want to share a conversation I overheard before Shavuos.  An older boy was speaking to a younger chavrusa and asking him where he intended to spend the Yom Tov.  This younger boy said that he planned to go the shul X, where they were known to have a lavish buffet going all night.  “But,” said the older boy, “This is your yeshiva!”  (I will spare you the details of the ensuing debate among the boys as to whether the yeshiva would allow a small grill to be brought in to provide this younger boy with his needed calories; suffice it to say that as far as I know, it didn’t happen.)  It’s not the Rosh Yeshiva’s yeshiva, the Rebbeim’s yeshiva, or anyone else’s yeshiva – you have to make it your business to be here to learn, this boy recognized, because it’s YOUR yeshiva.  And showing up is just half the picture -- this older bachur did more than show up himself; he communicated to those around him why it was important to do so. 

Don’t you wish you have an older chavrusa like that when you were a teenager?

My son is a quiet type, but somehow he doesn't have a moment of his day to himself.  He doesn’t only have chavrusas with beis medrash chaveirim who he knows well and has been together with for years, but he has younger guys who he learns with as well – he has a twice a week mishmar with a 9th grader, he has a chavursa with an 8th grader learning mishnayos, he has a halacha seder with someone else in the mesivta, he just asked me about setting up a night seder during the summer with a 10th grader who asked to learn with him.  This is a boy who is perfectly happy when he gets the chance in the summer to sit in a beis medrash with no chavrusa and just keeping finishing masechtos.  But that’s not how the yeshiva operates – you can’t help but be drawn into helping the next guy, setting up yet another chavrusa when someone (especially a younger bachur) asks.  It’s not enough to finish the masechta yourself – what have you done to help the other guy do the same?

And again, I am a cynic (I prefer the term “realist”).  I can appreciate why a parent might say, “Why should I send my son to a yeshiva where there are bachurim more concerned with spending Shavuos night, of all times, fressing rather than be in yeshiva?”  This why we have a proliferation of yeshivos, each one of which tries to be more exclusive, to take only the idis she’b’idis she’b’idis; we have parents competing for their metzuyanim (what parent does not think their child is a metzuyan?) to gain entrance into these exclusive clubs.  It could be that this is what your child needs; it could be that the Shavuos fresser will drag him down and create an environment that is not conducive for growth.  What chinuch is best for your child is a personal decision.  All I can say is that 70 boys finishing Kesubos, which by my guesstimate is close to a third of the yeshiva, are enough proof for my own cynical reservations that the that the system works – that they not only are not dragged down where they are, but that they elevate and inspire those around them, myself included.